Website Redesign SEO: Will a New Site Hurt Your Rankings?
A redesign only hurts Google rankings when page addresses, content or technical basics change carelessly. Here is what to keep, redirect and…
David Ellis · 12 Nov 2026
Local SEO
We checked 170 Kent trade websites. Three in four we speed tested took over four seconds to show on a phone, and over one in five had no tap to call link.
On 15 November 2026 we looked at who Google shows when someone searches for a trade in a Kent town, then checked the websites of the local trade businesses that came up. Across 42 searches such as “plumber maidstone”, directories and marketplaces took 42% of the top 20 results, almost the same share as local trade businesses (43%). Of the 161 trade websites we could speed test, three in four (75%) took more than four seconds to show their main content on a phone. More than one in five (22%) had no tap to call link, and only 55% passed all five of the basics we checked.
The good news: nearly every site is secure and set up for phones, and most gaps can be fixed on the site you already have.
We build websites for trade businesses across Kent. We wanted a fair, local answer to a simple question: is a trade website helping to win work, judged by what a customer in Maidstone or Margate actually sees? It follows our earlier research into the faults we found auditing an online shop.
We took the top 20 UK Google results, using the SEO tool Ahrefs, for eight trades in eight Kent towns: 64 searches in all. Of those, 42 returned results data, giving us 519 results and 204 local trade business websites. We checked each homepage the same day, as any visitor would see it. 170 loaded and were checked, and 161 completed Google’s Lighthouse test on its mobile setting. Full method and limits are at the end.
Of the 519 results in the top 20, 221 (43%) were local trade businesses and 216 (42%) were directories and marketplaces. National chains and lead generation sites took 46 (9%), social media pages 17 (3%), and news, council, jobs and merchant sites 19 (4%). In the top 10, directories edged ahead: 43.5% against 43.2%. The biggest trade directory appeared 54 times in the top 20, and another 38 times.
What it means: you are not just up against the firm down the road, but against directory pages that list your competitors side by side.
The fix: if you use directories, keep each listing complete, with exactly the same name, address and phone number as your website.
Of 170 sites, 165 (97%) load securely, with the padlock showing, and 157 (92%) send visitors from the old insecure address to the secure one. 160 (94%) are set up to fit a phone screen. Five (3%) had a certificate error.
What it means: the foundations are in place. But a certificate error can trigger a browser warning, which puts customers off.
The fix: open your site on your phone. If you see a warning, ask your host to renew the certificate.
Google’s Lighthouse test simulates a mid range phone on a slowed connection. Across 161 sites, the median mobile performance score was 68 out of 100. Only 24 (15%) scored 90 or more, and 9 (6%) scored under 50.
The clearest measure is Largest Contentful Paint: how long the main content takes to appear. The median was 6.1 seconds. Google counts 2.5 seconds or less as good. Only 16 sites (10%) managed it, and 120 (75%) took over four seconds. The median page weighed 1.9 MB, with 49 (30%) over 3 MB and 17 (11%) over 5 MB.
What it means: someone with a leaking pipe or a broken lock is often searching on a phone, in a hurry. Every second of blank screen is a chance to try the next result.
The fix: start with photos, often the heaviest part of a page. Resize them and save them as WebP. You can run the same test free on Google’s PageSpeed Insights. Our guides to speeding up a WordPress website and making a website mobile friendly go step by step.
Of the 170 homepages, 132 (78%) have a tap to call link, so a visitor on a phone can ring with one tap. The other 38 (22%) do not.
| Trade | Homepages with a tap to call link |
|---|---|
| Locksmiths | 91% |
| Boiler repair | 89% |
| Plumbers | 85% |
| Roofers | 85% |
| Electricians | 77% |
| Painters and decorators | 68% |
| Builders | 58% |
| Landscapers | 44% |
The landscaper and boiler repair groups are small, nine sites each, so read those two figures with care. The pattern fits what you might expect: trades that take urgent calls make calling easiest.
What it means: a customer who has to copy your number by hand might ring someone else instead.
The fix: make every phone number on your site a tap to call link. It is a one line change, and worth it even for planned work. Our pages on web design for plumbers and electricians show where we put the number.
Structured data is a small block of code, invisible to visitors, that tells Google who you are, what you do, where and how to call. 90 sites (53%) had some business or organisation structured data, but only 59 (35%) used the local business type.
What it means: it will not guarantee a higher ranking, but it helps Google get your details right.
The fix: add LocalBusiness structured data, or the closest type for your trade, such as Plumber or Electrician. Several WordPress SEO plugins can do this. Then check it with Google’s free Rich Results Test.
Of the 117 sites that show a copyright year, 27 (23%) show 2024 or earlier, and 18 (15%) show 2022 or earlier. Separately, 31 sites (18%) show a free email address on the homepage, such as Gmail, Hotmail or BT Internet.
What it means: neither stops anyone getting work, and plenty of good firms use a free email address. But to a customer comparing quotes, an old date can make a site look unattended.
The fix: set the year to update itself, and use an email address on your own domain.
Google often shows your page title and meta description in its results. The main heading, the H1, says what the page is about.
What it means: these are often the first words a customer reads about you, before they decide whether to click.
The fix: give each page its own title under 65 characters, trade and town first, such as “Emergency Plumber in Maidstone | Your Business Name”, plus a short description and one clear main heading. Our guide to why a website is not showing on Google covers what to check next.
Lighthouse also scores accessibility: how easy a page is to use for someone with poor sight or a screen reader. The median was 89, and 82 of 161 sites (51%) scored below 90. Of 159 sites with two or more images, 45 (28%) were missing alt text, the description a screen reader reads aloud, on more than half of them.
What it means: a site that is easier for some customers is usually easier for all of them. Alt text also helps Google understand your photos.
The fix: give each photo a short, plain description, such as “new slate roof on a terraced house in Chatham”.
On the homepage, 112 sites (66%) mention reviews or testimonials, 78 (46%) have a contact form and 66 (39%) mention a trade accreditation such as Gas Safe, NICEIC, NAPIT, TrustMark or FMB.
What it means: some sites show these on other pages, and not every trade has an accreditation scheme. But the homepage is often a customer’s first look, so proof works hardest there.
The fix: put two or three short reviews near the top, show the registrations you hold, and add a short form for people who would rather not call. Our page on web design for tradesmen covers what a trade homepage needs.
84 sites (49%) run on WordPress, followed by Wix with 13 (8%), Squarespace 4, Duda 3, the GoDaddy builder 2 and the Hostinger builder 1. The other 63 used something else or could not be identified.
What it means, and the fix: in our view, setup matters more than platform. Sort the basics before thinking about a rebuild.
We picked five basics every trade homepage should have: a secure connection, the mobile setting, a tap to call link, a meta description and exactly one main heading. 94 of the 170 sites (55%) had all five.
What it means: the rest already rank in the top 20, yet miss at least one simple thing. None of the five needs a new website.
The fix: work through the checklist below.
The 16 sites in positions 1 to 3 had a median mobile performance score of 66. The 145 in positions 4 to 20 had 68. With a small group and a small gap, this is no firm conclusion, but it suggests speed alone does not put a trade site at the top. Relevance, reviews and links from other sites are likely to matter more.
What it means: a speed fix alone may not lift your ranking. Do it for the customers who visit.
Out of 170 trade homepages checked, unless stated otherwise.
| What we measured | Result |
|---|---|
| Local trade businesses in the top 20 | 221 of 519 (43%) |
| Directories and marketplaces in the top 20 | 216 of 519 (42%) |
| Top 10: directories and local businesses | 43.5% and 43.2% |
| Load securely | 165 (97%) |
| Set up for mobile | 160 (94%) |
| Median mobile performance score | 68 out of 100 (161 sites) |
| Median time for main content to appear | 6.1 seconds |
| Main content within 2.5 seconds | 16 of 161 (10%) |
| Main content took over 4 seconds | 120 of 161 (75%) |
| Tap to call link | 132 (78%) |
| LocalBusiness structured data | 59 (35%) |
| Free email address on the homepage | 31 (18%) |
| Copyright year 2024 or earlier | 27 of 117 (23%) |
| Page title missing or over 65 characters | 52 (31%) |
| Accessibility score below 90 | 82 of 161 (51%) |
| Mention reviews or testimonials | 112 (66%) |
| Mention a trade accreditation | 66 (39%) |
| Pass all five basics | 94 (55%) |
The order we would work in, quickest wins first.
Our website audit checklist covers each of these in more detail. If you would like us to check your own site against the same list, just ask.
Journalists, business groups and newsletters are welcome to quote these findings. Please credit Kent Web Design and link to this page, so readers can see the method. The figures are a snapshot of 15 November 2026.
We checked 170 local trade business homepages on 15 November 2026. They came from the top 20 Google results for 42 searches, such as "plumber maidstone", covering eight trades in eight Kent towns. We found 204 local business websites in total, but 34 could not be checked and were left out.
They take about as many spots. In our study, directories and marketplaces held 42% of the top 20 results and local trade businesses held 43%. In the top 10 alone, directories edged ahead with 43.5% against 43.2%. The biggest trade directory appeared 54 times in the top 20.
Google counts 2.5 seconds or less as good for the main content of a page to appear. In our study, only 10% of the 161 Kent trade sites we could test managed that on a simulated mid range phone. The median was 6.1 seconds, and 75% took more than four seconds.
Not on its own, going by our sample. The 16 sites in positions 1 to 3 had a median mobile performance score of 66, against 68 for sites in positions 4 to 20. The group is small, so this is not a firm conclusion. Relevance, reviews and links are likely to matter more, but speed still matters to the customers who visit.
Start with the quick wins: make your phone number tap to call, check the site loads securely, write a clear page title and description with your trade and town, and give the homepage one main heading. Then add reviews and registrations to the homepage, LocalBusiness structured data, image descriptions, and finally lighter pages for phones.
Yes. Journalists, business groups and newsletters are welcome to quote them. Please credit Kent Web Design and link to this page so readers can see the method. The figures are a snapshot of 15 November 2026.
Get found
We build local SEO into every site so the right customers find you on Google.
A redesign only hurts Google rankings when page addresses, content or technical basics change carelessly. Here is what to keep, redirect and…
David Ellis · 12 Nov 2026
Either Google has not indexed your site or something else ranks better. One search tells you which, and the fix for each…
Charlie Dean · 12 Nov 2026
SEO web design means building a website search engines can find, read, and rank. Here is how structure, speed, mobile and content…
David Ellis · 21 Nov 2026