3D Secure Payment Failed? What It Means and What to Do
A customer says their card payment failed, but nothing is wrong with your shop. What 3D Secure is, why the check fails,…
Paul Fletcher · 2 Oct 2026
Development
Shopify or WooCommerce? UK plan prices, card fees worked out at two sales volumes, upkeep, flexibility and ownership, in plain English.
Shopify and WooCommerce are the two platforms most UK small businesses end up choosing between for an online shop. Shopify is a hosted service you rent by the month. WooCommerce is free software that turns a WordPress website into a shop you own. This guide compares them on real UK costs, card fees, ease of use, upkeep, flexibility and ownership, with worked examples at two sales volumes, so you can see which one fits how you sell.
Choose Shopify if you want to run the shop yourself with as little technical upkeep as possible, and you are happy to pay a monthly fee and work within its system. Choose WooCommerce if you want to own the site outright, keep card fees as low as possible, sell alongside a content rich website, or need the shop to do something a standard template cannot. WooCommerce needs looking after, so it suits businesses with a developer or a care plan behind them.
Ownership. Shopify is a hosted platform: Shopify runs the software and the hosting, and you pay a monthly subscription to use them. WooCommerce is a free plugin for WordPress: you install it on your own hosting, so you own the site, the design and the data, and you choose who hosts it and who maintains it.
Both are big, established platforms. WooCommerce has more than seven million active installations, according to its WordPress.org listing. Shopify runs on 5.3% of all websites, according to W3Techs in October 2026. Neither is a risky choice.
Shopify’s main UK plans, as listed on its pricing page on 19 October 2026:
| Plan | Billed monthly | Billed yearly (per month) | Shopify Payments online card rate | Extra fee with another payment provider |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | £25 | £19 | 2% + 25p | 2% |
| Grow | £65 | £49 | 1.7% + 25p | 1% |
| Advanced | £344 | £259 | 1.5% + 25p | 0.6% |
On top of the plan, many shops pay for a theme (Shopify lists 24 free themes and well over a thousand paid ones) and a handful of apps, which are usually monthly subscriptions. Check at checkout whether VAT is added to the plan price.
The WooCommerce plugin itself is free. What you pay for is everything around it:
For what a professionally built shop costs on either platform, see our guide to ecommerce website costs.
WooCommerce, usually, because you choose the payment provider and no platform fee is added on top. Published UK rates on 19 October 2026:
| Provider | Standard UK card rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Stripe (with WooCommerce) | 1.5% + 20p | 2.5% + 20p for European cards, 3.15% + 20p for other international cards |
| WooPayments | 1.5% + 25p | Extra 2% for international cards, no monthly fee |
| PayPal | 2.9% + 30p | Extra fee for cross border payments |
| Shopify Payments, Basic plan | 2% + 25p | Lower on Grow and Advanced |
Apple Pay and Google Pay run through these providers, so they are available on both platforms. The Canterbury watch dealer we moved off a hosted platform this year, onto a custom built shop it owns, takes orders through Stripe, PayPal, Apple Pay and Google Pay. You can read how that project went.
A worked example using standard UK cards, £50 orders, yearly billing, Shopify Basic with Shopify Payments, and WooCommerce with Stripe. WooCommerce hosting is left out because it varies, so add your hosting to that column.
| Monthly sales | Shopify Basic: plan + card fees | WooCommerce + Stripe: card fees only | Difference before hosting |
|---|---|---|---|
| £2,000 (40 orders) | £19 + £50 = £69 | £38 | £31 a month |
| £10,000 (200 orders) | £19 + £250 = £269 | £190 | £79 a month |
The gap grows with your sales, because Shopify Basic’s card rate is higher than Stripe’s standard rate. Moving to Shopify Grow lowers the card rate but raises the plan fee, so at £10,000 a month it works out at about the same £269. On WooCommerce, the gap pays for hosting and upkeep. Apps on Shopify and paid extensions on WooCommerce can shift the numbers either way, so price up the specific features you need.
Shopify, at the start. You sign up, pick a theme, add products and take payments without touching hosting, updates or security. Its admin is built around orders, and its mobile app lets you run the shop from your phone.
WooCommerce has a steeper start, because someone has to set up the hosting, the theme and the payments. Once built well, day to day running is just as manageable. On the shops we hand over, owners add products, change prices, mark items sold and dispatch orders with tracking, all from their phone.
WooCommerce. WordPress, WooCommerce, the theme and every plugin get regular updates, and on a shop those updates need doing promptly and testing, because a broken checkout costs money by the hour. Backups need to run and be checked. That is the real cost of ownership, and it is why most WooCommerce shops have a developer or a care plan. Our guides on WordPress maintenance packages and backing up a WordPress site explain what that involves.
Shopify handles updates and security for you. Its upkeep is different rather than absent: apps change, themes need updating, and access has to be managed. On one client’s Shopify store, we were locked out of the theme files for over a week because their account kept giving us the wrong staff role. We worked it out through Shopify’s live chat and told the client exactly which role to set. Small things like that are part of running any platform.
WooCommerce. Because it is open source and runs on your own hosting, it can be changed to do almost anything: custom product options, unusual pricing, trade accounts, bookings, memberships, or a shop that sits inside a large content site. Shopify’s thousands of apps cover most needs, but you are always working within what Shopify allows, and each app adds a subscription.
Both can rank well. WooCommerce gives you full control over every page, web address and piece of code, and WordPress is strong for content, so it suits shops that will grow through guides and articles as well as product pages. Shopify covers the essentials but has some fixed web address patterns you cannot change. In practice, product descriptions, page titles, images and speed decide rankings far more than the platform does. Our guide to improving WordPress speed covers the main lever on WooCommerce.
| Shopify | WooCommerce | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Hosted ecommerce platform | Free plugin for WordPress |
| Ownership | You rent the platform | You own the site and data |
| Monthly platform fee | From £19 billed yearly | None, but you pay for hosting |
| Card fees | From 2% + 25p on Basic, extra fee with other providers | Your provider’s rate, for example Stripe 1.5% + 20p |
| Getting started | Quick to set up yourself | Needs setting up properly |
| Upkeep | Handled by Shopify | Updates and backups needed |
| Flexibility | High, within Shopify’s rules | Almost unlimited |
| Best for | Hands on owners who want simplicity | Businesses that want ownership and lower fees |
We build shops on WordPress, so weigh this accordingly. We recommend it because our clients own what they pay for, we take no fee on their sales beyond the standard Stripe and PayPal charges, and the shop can be shaped around how they actually sell. We also look after the updates, which removes WooCommerce’s main drawback.
If you want to run everything yourself with no developer involved, Shopify is a good platform and we will tell you so. If you are also weighing Squarespace, read our Squarespace vs Shopify comparison, and for the wider platform picture see Wix vs WordPress vs Squarespace. Whatever you pick, our online shop audit findings show the checkout mistakes to avoid.
Plan prices, card rates and extension prices come from Shopify, WooCommerce, Stripe and PayPal’s own UK pages, checked on 19 October 2026. The worked examples are our own arithmetic from those figures. Usage figures are from WordPress.org and W3Techs. The Shopify access problem and the watch dealer project are our own work.
Shopify is simpler to start and has no upkeep, but you pay a monthly fee and higher card rates for that. WooCommerce costs less per sale and you own it, but it needs looking after. If you are not sure which fits, tell us what you sell and we will give you a straight answer.
Shopify suits owners who want to run the shop themselves with no technical upkeep and are happy paying a monthly fee. WooCommerce suits businesses that want to own the site outright, keep card fees low or need custom features, and have a developer or care plan to keep it updated.
The WooCommerce plugin is free. You still pay for hosting, a domain name, card processing to your payment provider, any paid extensions you need (WooCommerce Subscriptions is £213 a year, for example) and someone to build and maintain the site.
Usually WooCommerce. Stripe charges 1.5% plus 20p for standard UK cards with no platform fee on top, while Shopify Basic with Shopify Payments charges 2% plus 25p (UK rates checked 19 October 2026). At £10,000 a month in £50 orders, that is about £79 a month less in fees before hosting.
Yes. If you use a payment provider other than Shopify Payments, Shopify adds its own fee on each sale: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow and 0.6% on Advanced, on top of the provider's charges.
Yes. WordPress, WooCommerce, the theme and plugins all need regular updates, tested promptly on a live shop, and backups need checking. Shopify handles updates and security itself. That upkeep is the main trade off for owning a WooCommerce site.
Both can rank well. WooCommerce gives full control over pages, web addresses and code, and WordPress is strong for content. Shopify covers the essentials but has some fixed web address patterns. Product descriptions, titles, images and speed matter more than the platform.
Yes. Apple Pay and Google Pay run through payment providers such as Stripe, so they work on WooCommerce as well as Shopify. A Canterbury watch dealer we built for takes orders through Stripe, PayPal, Apple Pay and Google Pay.
Free quote
Tell us what you do and we will come back with clear, honest next steps.
A customer says their card payment failed, but nothing is wrong with your shop. What 3D Secure is, why the check fails,…
Paul Fletcher · 2 Oct 2026
An ecommerce website costs about £3,000 to £15,000 plus transaction fees. What drives the price, the costs people miss, and whether you…
David Ellis · 19 Oct 2026
Website development costs £300 for a template setup to five figures for logins and payments. What you are paying for, where the…
Paul Fletcher · 4 Oct 2026